Tyler Hanes as Caldwell B. Cladwell (all performances)

Tilly Taufmann as Penelope Pennywise (all performances)

Siobhan McNulty as Officer Lockstock (1st 2 performances-A)

Johanna Sodke as Mr. McQueen (1st 2 performances-A)

Siobhan McNulty as Mr. McQueen (last 2 performances-B)

Johanna Sodke as Officer Lockstock (last 2 performances-B)

Hannah Hafner as Little Sally (A)

Hannah Hafner as Robby the Stockfish/Dr. Billeaux (B)

Rosanna Takhsh as Robby the Stockfish/Dr. Billeaux (A)

Rosanna Takhsh as Little Sally (B)

Lauren Krakora as Senator Fipp (All Performances)

Ava Martin as Little Becky/Mrs. Millennium (All performances)

Pau Maset as Officer Barrel (All performances)

Sophie Mazzella as Soupy Sue (All Performances)

Marisa Morgan as Hot Blades Harry (A)

Ella Schultz as Hope Cladwell (A)

Marisa Morgan as Hope Cladwell (B)

Ella Schultz as Hot Blades Harry (B)

Liam O'Farrell as Bobby Strong (A)

Jonah Sarno as Billy Boy Bill (A)

Liam O'Farrell as Billy Boy Bill (B)

Jonah Sarno as Bobby Strong (B)

Sara Sodke as Josephine Strong (All Performances)

Ramman Takhsh as Old Man Strong (All performances)

Lucas Wernek Fraga as Tiny Tom (All Performances)